This is a good plan this sounds a lot like most social workers revolution from below, and this is compatible with the concept of Marxist "Dictatorship of the proletariat" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictatorship_of_the_proletariat this revolutionary concept, tactic, strategy, system of "dictatorship of the proletariat", provisional government, transitional government should be made public and mainstream to all people who hate Democrats, Republicans the oligarchy the ruling classes but who stay away from politics because they don't really have the necessary knowledge on how to save USA or how to overthrow an oligarchic class and replace it by a government of the oppressed and working classes.
This is why i support your project for a transitional revolutionary government toward a path, toward a workers government. This is a great article i will share it with friends and families (even if they are too cold for revolutionary political activism which is what is needed right now to save the world from the global zionist jewish elites of trying to steal the whole for themselves
What you are suggesting is mob rule. There's no such a thing as a patriotic Marxist dictatorship of the working class. It's replaces one tyranny with another. It does not value Freedom and does not defend it. It only imposed its will violently in a mob rule situation. That's not what Emanuel P is suggesting!
Yes, Emmanuel is indeed suggesting a dictatorship of the oppressed against the overthrown oppressors. You have to get used to the fact that a revolution is a dictatorship, and that all governments right-wingers, left-wingers or revolutionary governments are dictatorships (that's a fact) and that only in an anarchist-communist political system (in the future, not today) you will not see dictatorships over one class over another class
Read more about the origin of the governments, and the nature of what is a government (whether it is a right-wing, or left-wing). All states, all governments are dictatorships of one class over other classes. If you hate a class and a state oppressing you, then try to install byt yourself, an anarchist system in USA, which is the only way you will be totally free of a dictatorship. But installing an anarchist system in America right now it is almost impossible.
And yes, what Emmanuel is suggesting is just none other than a dictatorship, but a different dictatorship (a revolutionary emergency dictatorship, oppressing and repressing the overthrown capitalist class.
So again there are good dictatorships and evil dictatorships. The US government is an evil dictatorship and USSR was a good dictatorship
The poor always remain poor in a communist dictatorship. And they are not allowed to have any choice for freedom. What that suggests is disconnection from reality. It's only a delusion. Socialism and communism always fail. And crony capitalism also fails because everything that is gained at the expense of others has the seed of destruction within it and will eventually fall by its own weight.
This is a good plan this sounds a lot like most social workers revolution from below, and this is compatible with the concept of Marxist "Dictatorship of the proletariat" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictatorship_of_the_proletariat this revolutionary concept, tactic, strategy, system of "dictatorship of the proletariat", provisional government, transitional government should be made public and mainstream to all people who hate Democrats, Republicans the oligarchy the ruling classes but who stay away from politics because they don't really have the necessary knowledge on how to save USA or how to overthrow an oligarchic class and replace it by a government of the oppressed and working classes.
This is why i support your project for a transitional revolutionary government toward a path, toward a workers government. This is a great article i will share it with friends and families (even if they are too cold for revolutionary political activism which is what is needed right now to save the world from the global zionist jewish elites of trying to steal the whole for themselves
What you are suggesting is mob rule. There's no such a thing as a patriotic Marxist dictatorship of the working class. It's replaces one tyranny with another. It does not value Freedom and does not defend it. It only imposed its will violently in a mob rule situation. That's not what Emanuel P is suggesting!
Yes, Emmanuel is indeed suggesting a dictatorship of the oppressed against the overthrown oppressors. You have to get used to the fact that a revolution is a dictatorship, and that all governments right-wingers, left-wingers or revolutionary governments are dictatorships (that's a fact) and that only in an anarchist-communist political system (in the future, not today) you will not see dictatorships over one class over another class
Read more about the origin of the governments, and the nature of what is a government (whether it is a right-wing, or left-wing). All states, all governments are dictatorships of one class over other classes. If you hate a class and a state oppressing you, then try to install byt yourself, an anarchist system in USA, which is the only way you will be totally free of a dictatorship. But installing an anarchist system in America right now it is almost impossible.
And yes, what Emmanuel is suggesting is just none other than a dictatorship, but a different dictatorship (a revolutionary emergency dictatorship, oppressing and repressing the overthrown capitalist class.
So again there are good dictatorships and evil dictatorships. The US government is an evil dictatorship and USSR was a good dictatorship
The dictatorship of the proletariat is real democracy, is a government and dictatorship of the workers and poor people against the rich. Go to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictatorship_of_the_proletariat
I rest my case, if you are not convinced, i cannot do any thing about it
The poor always remain poor in a communist dictatorship. And they are not allowed to have any choice for freedom. What that suggests is disconnection from reality. It's only a delusion. Socialism and communism always fail. And crony capitalism also fails because everything that is gained at the expense of others has the seed of destruction within it and will eventually fall by its own weight.